Accident Database

Report ID# 118173

Help
  • Other
  • Hypothermia
  • Cold Water
  • Solo Paddling
  • High Water

Accident Description

HE WAS FOUND TODAY 5/22 UNINJURED

Solo paddler, high water

Missing rafter, Middle Fork of the Salmon River, Valley County
 
On 05/20/2024 the Valley County Sheriff's Office received a report of a possible missing rafter on the Middle Fork of the Salmon River on the eastern border of Valley County, bordering Custer County. We have been in contact with the family of Thomas Gray, a 73-year-old male from North Fork Idaho. Mr. Gray is an experienced rafter and has completed this run several times.
 
Mr. Gray put in at Marsh Creek on Friday May 17th and was expected to be at the confluence of the main Salmon River on May 19th. His purple Maravia Cataraft has been located and last seen north of the Boundary Creek launch.
 
We are asking for information from anyone who may have been on the Middle Fork of the Salmon River from Friday May 17th from Marsh Creek to Indian Creek that might have seen or had contact with Mr. Gray. We are not requesting any assistance at this time, as we have launched multiple resources including the Valley County Search and Rescue in the search for Mr. Gray. If you have information, please contact our dispatch center at 208-382-5160. Thank you in advance.

 

From Michael Wellman: I'm going to assume you're not overy familiar with the Middle Fork. Even though I'm Virginia based, I've managed 50+ trips on it in the last 40'sh years. Murph's Hole is .9 miles below Boundary Creek, so if he got in trouble at Dagger Falls (just above Boundary Creek), his boat could easily have made it to Murph's. Two weeks back there were purportedly 4 river wide blockages on Marsh creek and recent trips reported at least two portages before Boundary. And Dagger also is a legit hazard at current water levels. 

Boaters will probably punch the road into Boundary in the next few days, but right now there's not anyone there to help if he was separated from his raft. There's a private inholding ranch up Sulphur Creek, but that's river mile 3.2 (from Boundary). It's possible he got separated and made the river left shore…and one doesn't easily try to swim across the upper Middle Fork at 5'+ to get to a river right stranded raft. There’s a good trail downstream from Boundary on river left, but upstream of Dagger, it’s a lot more bushwhacking, but undoubtedly there’s treacherous snow still in places even on the trail. And there's not a ton of trail bridges across the Middle Fork if one is on the wrong side.

This time of year, barring terrible weather, there's a trip or two coming down Marsh Creek every day. So if one lost one's boat, the best bet would be trying to flag one of them down. Although eddies on Marsh Creek and the first 25 miles of the Middle Fork proper are hard to come by at these levels… All in all, sadly, I have to think this will more likely be a recovery than a rescue if he's located.

That having been said, someone swam in high water in the Impassable Canyon (the bottom 20 miles) many years ago and flushed the last 10 miles of the Middle Fork and lived to tell the tale. At high water, my GPS has reported speeds between 15 and 20 mph on the Middle Fork. So, there’s arguably still hope. Few Idaho rafters carry satellite phones and most who do have them secured in an ammo can on their raft. Which is unhandy when one loses one’s raft. With the newer satellite enabled mobile phones for emergency SMS messages, there’s hope that one can further mitigate this risk.

But on a single boat trip, down Marsh, in May, on high water here’s a lot of assumed risk there. This year’s probable peak flow was May 17, at 5.6 feet, nearly 6000 cfs, although admittedly the gauge is river mile 35. But that means his launch date was at peak flow.

 

 
Now that we know he's well I will share our experience. We arrived at Marsh Creek put-in about 9:30am and saw Mr. Gray rigging his boat. He pushed off alone some minutes later and about 20-30 minutes ahead of our group. Each of the kayakers there took notice of the situation - he was both older and alone. But he looked happy, had a warm smile and was ready to push off on an incredible adventure.

Around five miles in, we saw that there was a river wide tree that had recently been cut making a narrow passage on the left. It wasn't reasonable for a raft to get around this on the left side, and his boat was stuffed into and under this log. Mr. Gray was on top of the log with his boat pinned against it and he wasn't making much progress trying to free it.

I was in a group of seven. Three of us ran the slot on the left and began trying to assist. I got out on shore and grabbed my rope. At the same time my friend had a saw in his PFD pocket and quickly assisted by sawing at the biggest limb hanging off the bottom of the tree. Within seconds, a loud "swoosh" and the boat was freed underneath the tree but Mr. Gray stayed on top of the tree. The boat quickly went around the corner with my two friends chasing it. I stayed with the gentlemen and assured that he made it entirely onto shore. He was grateful, saying "thank you" a few times before then looking at me and saying "21 trips down Marsh Creek and this is the first time I've been bit." He started walking downstream, hoping to find his boat. I then helped the ladies in our group upstream portage the log and over a half hour passed before we proceeded downstream and around the corner, where the other two friends had pushed his raft close to shore in some bushes. His boat was stuck, but not pinned. It was most likely upside down. He was going to need to get his gear in order before proceeding downstream, but he was safe and well with his boat, and we no longer felt that he needed our assistance. I think our group was probably a little irritated that he predictably ran into trouble and needed our help. There was another group of kayakers that encountered him at the same spot some time later and he was still getting his gear in order. At this time, they also advised that he hike out and he was asked if he had a GPS device such as an inReach, apparently he had not.

As we pushed downstream, I began to worry that we had left him in enough of a mess that the kayakers in the party behind us might have to help him. It sounds like they had a short conversation and Mr. Gray indicated he was going to continue downstream. At this time, both parties of kayakers had passed him and I don't believe anybody else was upstream of him that day.

For the next three days, our group worried about Mr. Gray, but we enjoyed our time as a group. As we were a few hundred yards away from the confluence, I could see a car that watched us and then drove just downstream. At this time, Mr. Gray's wife waved us over because she needed information. He was supposed to take off the day before, Sunday the 19th. The conversation with her was simply heartwrenching as you could see the worry in her face and hear it in her voice. I was nearly in tears.

As we drove into Salmon, we called all the available Forest Service and Sheriff resources to alert them of our experience.

As it's been a couple days since, I had nearly assumed too much time had passed. He never checked into Indian Creek. I wondered if he had planned to run Dagger Falls as it's not a short portage for an older guy to do alone in his cataraft. Sitting at work this afternoon after losing sleep these last few days, and seeing the good news, was an intense feeling of relief and elation!


 
****MAY 23, 2024****
MISSING PERSON UPDATE
***THOMAS GRAY***
On May 20, 2024 at 3:51 pm Custer County Sheriff’s Office received a report of a punctured cata-raft being found on the Middle Fork of the Salmon River. Valley County Sheriff’s Office was currently searching for a 73 year old male, Thomas Gray, who had been operating the vessel. At 9:16 am on May 21, Custer County Search and Rescue was activated by Sheriff Levi Maydole. Valley County Search and Rescue sent a 2 man kayak team to float Marsh Creek. The team was unable to locate Mr. Gray. Custer County Sheriff Deputies also searched the launch site on Hwy 21. Civil Air Patrol flew the river from Boundary Creek to Indian Creek several times, but were unable to locate Mr. Gray.
On May 22, at approximately 11:30 Steve Lentz notified Valley County Sheriff’s Office which in turn notified Custer County Sheriff Maydole that Mr. Gray had been located and was safe. Custer County Marine Deputy John Haugh and Custer County Deputy Levi Mitchell were able to meet Mr. Gray at the Mountain Village Restaurant in Stanley Idaho. Marine Deputy Haugh gave Mr. Gray a ride to Custer County Sheriff’s Office where was reunited with his wife.
Mr. Gray Launched from Marsh Creek on May 17. A series of log jams on Marsh creek caused the vessel to have to be disassembled and Mr. Gray, having sustained a leg injury, to camp along the bank of Marsh Creek that night. When Mr. gray arrived at Dagger Falls the following day, he decided to run the falls, as he did not want to delay meeting his wife at the confluence on Sunday May 19. He was then flipped and ejected at the base of Dagger falls and he swam to shore. He then climbed up the mountain and, realizing he could not recover his vessel, he hiked toward Boundary Creek Launch site. Due to the leg injury he sustained on Marsh Creek, Mr. Gray stayed at the launch site, finding shelter in the outhouse for 2 nights, keeping watch in the daytime for other floaters on the Middle Fork, who could assist him.
After 2 days of not finding help he decided to walk towards Fir Creek Pass. Mr. Gray does not have recollection of the 3rd night. On May 21, Mr. Gray was able to find Shelter in the Bruce Meadows Snowmobile Club trailer. In the trailer there was a wood stove, but there were no matches to be found. On May 22, Mr. Gray awoke and continued down Bear Valley Rd. Three miles below the pass, Mr. Gray became too exhausted to continue, this is where he laid down in the snow. Mr. Gray had walked approximately 23 miles between the dates of May 19 and may 22. Mr. Gray had no food and was only able to drink out of creeks and eat snow.
Steve and Annie Lentz who own Far and Away River Adventures were heading into Boundary creek in the morning of May 22, 2024. They spotted Mr. Gray lying in the snow alongside the road. Mr. Gray was alerted by the sound of the vehicle as the occupants discovered him. The Lentz party had several first responders on board, who immediately began to render aid. They identified him as the lost boater due to his attire. They transported Mr. Gray to the Mountain Village where he met with Custer County Deputies.
Custer County Sheriff Levi Maydole would like to thank Valley County Sheriff’s Office, Civil Air Patrol, the Lentz’s, and all who helped create a positive ending to this situation.
 

Rafter survives after embarking on a solo trip on the Middle Fork of the Salmon River

I called rafter Thomas Gray after he was back at his home in North Fork, Idaho. We wanted to learn more about his harrowing tale of survival.

By: Steve Dent, Idaho News 6

May 27, 2024

STANLEY, Idaho — I called rafter Thomas Gray after he was back at his home in North Fork, Idaho. Gray has more than four decades of rafting experience and he's been running the Middle Fork of the Salmon through Marsh Creek for more than a decade.

His story of survival is a testament to his will to live, but he made several crucial mistakes that put him in a tough spot in the Frank Church Wilderness of No Return west of Stanley.

The Middle Fork of the Salmon River is one of the premiere multi-day river expeditions in the United States. However, for boaters to float this remote stretch in June, July and August they have to win a permit in a lottery with the odds being around two percent.

"I put in for a permit, of course I didn’t get one, as usual," said Gray. "I've been running this stretch through Marsh Creek since 2011."

Boaters have an easier time getting a pre-season permit in May. However, during this time the road to the Boundary Creek put-in remains closed because of snow. This forces boaters to put-in at Marsh Creek which is notorious for having wood hazards around blind corners. That's where Gray first ran into trouble about seven miles in.

"There was a lot of current by then," said Gray. "I came around the corner and the logs totally blocked it, except for one spot about five feet wide on the left. So I rowed with all my heart to get to the left side and I got about half way because I was on the right side. I wish I would have known it was there, I would have been on the left side to start."

Gray pinned his cataraft on the log and climbed on top of the log. A short time later a group of kayakers came by and helped Gray free the vessel. It floated downstream where Gray retrieved it and said goodbye to the kayakers while he worked to put all the pieces back.

"The kayakers saved my bacon actually," said Gray.

 

Gray camped along Marsh Creek, but this ordeal put him well behind on his goal of meeting his wife and daughter at the confluence of the Middle Fork and the Main Salmon. He does solo trips now because the last time someone came with him, his brother drowned in Dagger Falls.

Gray scouted Dagger Falls and decided to run the rapid because he didn't want to delay any longer. He had run Dagger Falls three times before without a problem, but the Middle Fork was running at around 6,000 cubic feet per second on Saturday, May 18.

"I made the fateful decision," said Gray. "I’m going to float it, what is the chance of me going over? Well, that was my big mistake."

Gray flipped in the rapid hitting his leg on the oar lock on the way out. He was able to swim to shore and although he searched for his cat, he never found it. There went all his food, his clothing, his shelter, sleeping bag and all his supplies.

Gray took shelter in an outhouse at Boundary Creek where he stayed for two nights to get out of the elements as best he could. He was able to get all his gear dry except for his socks.

"Never try to sleep in one of those outhouse, you know why?" asked Gray. "Because they have concrete floors. I was frozen, I’ve never been so cold in my life. I’m thought I'm not going to make it, I’m going to freeze to death so I walked all night in that outhouse in the pitch dark."

Gray made up his mind the next day to start the 21-mile journey back to Highway 21 along a snow covered road. After about 12-miles Gray reached the Bruce Meadows Air Strip where he found a small cabin unlocked where he stayed another night.

"I walk into the cabin and there is a fireplace and there is wood." said Gray. "I thought, I’m going to be warm tonight, but I don’t have matches. At least it didn’t have a concrete floor, but I discovered the wood floor didn’t make a whole lot of difference."

The next morning Gray started off over the pass, but at this point he hadn't ate anything for four days, he drank water from streams or ate snow. He almost reached the summit when he laid down.

"I’ve been a Christian for a long time and I was praying, 'Lord, don’t let me die'," said Gray. "I was getting so tired, I would sit down. It was hard for me to get back up on my feet, I would take little naps and then I heard a noise."

 

Gray's luck finally changed as Steve and Annie Lentz of Far Away Adventures drove over the pass with a crew. They were on their way to access the situation at Velvet Rapid because there was a landslide that dumped a bunch of wood into this rapid and they were hoping to clear out some of the debris.

They found Gray, still in his river gear. The 73-year-old man was rescued and they brought him back to civilization. Thomas Gray survived a harrowing adventure in the Frank Church Wilderness of No Return to be reunited with his wife who was worried when Gray didn't show up.

"They gave me a little food and I hopped in their truck," said Gray. "It was the first heat I’ve had in four days, it was wonderful."

Thomas Gray made several mistakes including being on the river by himself. It's always a good idea to have other people with you, especially on a wilderness overnight expedition.

Gray should never have let running behind influence his decision on the river and he paid for it at Dagger Falls. He had also never heard of a Garmin InReach, but if he had a satellite communication device he could have called in a rescue at Boundary Creek. However, he did show great resolve in hiking more then 20 miles — his will to survive and a little bit of luck all made this a happy ending.

 

Join AW and support river stewardship nationwide!